A Cartoonist’s Diary A Cartoonist’s Diary

Joyce Farmer: Day Two

Today is a pen and ink day, doing a piece of work for hire.

Does anyone out there still use a dip pen and ink? NOT Magic Markers which turn purple and fade in the sunlight, but real ink like India ink? FW Acrylic Artist's Ink is a little thicker than India ink; it has a glossy finish when it's dry. It's a marvelous ink, I've been using it for 30 years or more. It never succumbs to erasure unless you use sandpaper. I thin it by about 10% with distilled water, otherwise it lumps up too fast on the nib. One time I even washed off a badly done water color from the paper, and the acetate ink held on so well I could re-do the color afterward. FW Acrylic also works well with Rapidograph and other refillable fountain pens, though it shouldn't be left in them for a long time. I wouldn't use it in a Mont Blanc, though it would probably work just fine.

Then there is the pen. You can use any dip pen nib holder you want, but they are getting hard to find. I have a lot of the old Speedball holders, they work with any nib, but they are light weight and often don't hold the nib firmly enough. I found an aluminum holder, it works pretty much like an X-Acto knife holder, you screw down the tube to tighten the nib. I bought the last two in existence from some company in Utah, one of them worked, the other wouldn't screw, the threads were already stripped when it was delivered. So I've used this one pen holder for the last ten years or so. It is heavy and steady in the hand, you don't have to stress your tiny hand muscles to grip it tightly. It won't roll away when you relax your grip a bit.

Crow quill pens are in a class by themselves, the nibs are round and the penholders are short and cut to accommodate the round nib. Anyone who masters crow quill is a genius and I give him or her my utter respect.

Paper: For my work with endless pencil editing and erasures, I like Strathmore 2-ply Bristol paper. Less expensive if you buy it in bulk, large sheets, and quarter them with a paper cutter. I work 50% up which allows you to get detail without losing control of the drawing and especially the lettering.

This is becoming less of a diary than an art lesson.

Now for the nibs: Long ago, Larry Todd praised the Hunt Imperial 101 nibs, and I used them for years for regular artwork, not the lettering. But then I changed to Hunt's 99. My friend Karen's father died, she got a bunch of old nibs from him and gave many of them to me. Some of them were silver-plated steel nibs by a brand called Corporation. Wow! Smooth, long-lasting, the 109 is perfect for regular drawing, almost all of Special Exits was done With a Corporation 109, I have one left after all that cross-hatching. Even the internet doesn't mention this brand, it's probably been out of business for decades. I didn't see this point on antique pen nib sites either.

Lettering and calligraphy dip nibs are an entirely different ball game than drawing nibs. You need either a wedge-shape nib or a round or oval, something that will be held at a single angle and make a graceful line. Speedball has lots of these nibs, all for different purposes. The queen of the lettering/writing pens is the glass pen, they were popular in the 18th c. and made a recent comeback. Most of them are expensive and overly pretty and not well-balanced, they don't hold much ink, they don't give a good line. But there are exceptions. I had a cheap one, about $13. that had a spiral nib ending in a tiny ball that made a very clean, even line. They are fragile, I knew this, and carefully packed away this awesome pen every night in its case. One day, about half-way through lettering Special Exits, it snapped, the tip broke off, end of pen. It turns out that not only is the glass fragile, it is also relatively soft, so that its life span is short no matter how well you take care of it. I now use a Speedball B-6 for most of my lettering, it's serviceable and I try to keep from daydreaming about perfect dip pen nibs.

However: One fine day last January, we happened to be at the Getty Museum to see an exhibit of French books 1250-1500 AD, exquisitely illustrated and lettered. In the gift shop was a dip pen and nib for any dreamer with hubris enough to try to emulate the calligraphy in the old books. It looked good, the holder was out of hardwood and brass, delicate but sturdy. Good balance. I bought it for the holder. Upon trying it out at home, the nib was even better, a tiny, precise wedge shape perfect for doing 3/16th inch letters. It appears to be steel, it's imprinted "505 EF PRESBITERO MILANO." Uncial awaits.

Last but far from least: Relative Humidity. If the humidity is under 40%, as it often is here in the Southwest, don't frustrate yourself by attempting to use a dip pen. The ink lumps up, causing constant cleaning of the pen. Adding more water thins the ink too much. Where I live, the humidity stays too low for several months at a time, usually October-December. I seal off my studio with a plastic shower curtain (there's no door) and run a cheap hot pot from the local kitchen store until my humidity gauge reaches at least 45%. The best humidity is 60% and up, 80% is perfect. The humidity is currently 52%. You can sometimes find gauges at garden stores or on the internet.

Time to put nether end to chair and do some real work.

Joyce Farmer is best known for co-creating the Tits ‘n Clits comics anthology in the 1970s. Her graphic memoir Special Exits was a Fall 2010 release from Fantagraphics Books. She lives in Laguna Beach, CA.


3 Responses to Joyce Farmer: Day Two

  1. vollsticks says:

    Thanks for the "tool talk"! It's always nice to hear about makes of nib I haven't come across before. Never heard of those glass pens, either…Have you ever tried the "manga" G-Nibs? Japanese engineering at it's finest–the steel is lovely and thick but springy and responsive–and you don't have to use a "pulled" stroke like you do with most crowquills, you can make your marks in any direction.

  2. Dave says:

    The aluminum crow quill nib pen holders are still made, go to and search on pen holders, there are two versions, both very cheap. Just ordered some for myself. Other places carry them too, usually ceramics sites for some reason. Just google “aluminum crow quill pen holder” and you’ll find them.

  3. Dave says:

    FW ink is NOT recommended for fountain pens, nor Rapidographs. The orginal Steig Products FW India was what was made back in the 70’s and adored by graphic designers and artists back then, I used it and it didn’t clog fountain pens or rapidographs and would flow even after months in the pens. In the mid-90’s the Steig Brothers were getting up in their 80’s and they sold the company to Daler Rowney in the UK. The FW ink they make now is an acrylic and will quickly kill fountain pens or rapidographs.

    I was a huge fan of Steig Products inks, they made many outstanding inks that nothing else ever came close to. Last year I got back into cartooning and went looking for Steig FW and found out it was gone forever. I contacted a number of ink makers in the US to see if anyone could copy it from a vintage sample of FW over 40 years old that still works perfectly, none of them would even talk to me. So, I contacted Daler Rowney and they looked in their archives and found the original Steig FW formula and made a batch for myself and Elwood Smith to test out. They nailed it 99%. They tried doing a production batch and had some problems, but they are still working on bringing back this wonderful ink formula for everyone to use. I am praying real hard they figure out how to do it with modern materials and pull it off because this ink flows super well in fountain pens and rapidographs, is very black, and totally and completely waterproof. Its shelf life like the original is probably 40 years! There is currently no deep black waterproof india that works in fountain pens without clogging them up, except Platinum Carbon and its not a very good ink, doesn’t flow well and makes the nib feel scratchy. You have to clean it out almost immediately tool

    YES, I use dip pens and I’m sure many others do, markers are horrible, you just can’t get a real pen line out of a marker, they fade, turn purple, whiteout turns weird colors over it. Dip pens are magical, they are a little hard to learn but what worthwhile isn’t? Cartoon art from 150 years ago looks like it was drawn yesterday, marker art after ten years looks horrible. You really have to try alot of different nibs to find the one for YOU. No, you don’t have to be a genius to use a crow quill, I used to think that too. They take some time to loosen up and make good lines, you have to keep your pen angle a little low, use plate finish bristol, clean the nib off in lacquer thinner so the ink will stick to the nib. The 108 Hunt is a wonderful flexy quill nib that gives all kinds of lines, the 102 is less flexy but great for cross hatching tones. You can limber up a crowquill from being scratchy by drawing small circles on some wet 400 grit wet/dry sandpaper, to smoothe the point out……

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *