This Week’s Comics (9/6/17)

Tim and I are going to attempt the impossible and continue the consumer-guide portion of this column for a while, until we find someone who can also do the impossible, and come up with some version of this column that can continue.

Now, the downside of us doing this column is that Dan, despite his advanced age, beautiful wife and child, years of therapy, and a recent trip to see Tom Petty, still maintains a deep well of rage devoted exclusively to comics. Weird!

Not a great week this week, if you're into weeks. 


Scott Snyder John Romita Jr, et al.
I've tried to read these comics a bunch of times, but I can never get past a few pages. For me it's harder than reading anything else. Like, the panels are all funny sizes and the colors are soooo dark. And why is it so violent? I don't know. I'll tell you what I do like: I like that Jessica Jones on Netflix. That's the superhero comic I like to watch! And that's enough. But other people like this, I think?Anyhow, this has Two-Face in it, and collects issues 1-5. [$17] (DN)


Ethan Rilly
One of the half-dozen or so comics remaining that are often referred to as "the last real alternative comic book," this beautifully drawn Canadian anthology ends its biggest storyline with an all-Fran-and-Vicki issue. Rob Clough reviewed it for this site here. There probably won't be many more comics like these. [$10.



Brigitte Findakly, Lewis Trondheim
Here's the gist: "Poppies of Iraq is Brigitte Findakly's nuanced chronicle of her relationship with her homeland Iraq, co-written and drawn by her husband, the acclaimed cartoonist Lewis Trondheim." I'm sorry, friends, I tried this one, but I didn't like it. I've never liked Trondheim's comics, except that one about the fly from like 15 years ago. That was a good one. And I don't understand, other than the fun of working on it as a couple, which I actually think is a valid reason for doing anything, why this has pictures in it. Seems like maybe it would have been stronger as a prose book, since Trondheim is not a cartoonist who makes terribly specific images. Then again, Findakly's prose is pretty flat. I dunno. Good topic, good timing, not such a great execution. (DN)

Lars Fiske
I looked at the George Grosz book and thought, "Seriously?" How many more terrible cartoon biographies of artists that (gasp) employ the subject's style in the narrative? How many? And why? Why the hell would you want to read a series of strips about Grosz drawn in his style. Seriously. Why? It's worse than that terrible Dali book by Baudoin. Worse than the bad Pascin book by Sfar. And even worse than those terrible Picasso books. Cartoonists: Please stop. Stop this madness. Unless you have a good idea. Or unless your name is Tim Hensley. Please. (DN)

By George Carmona and Eric Doescher
You know who is going to love this book? My five-year-old boy. He loves jokes and he loves superheroes. I'm sure it's terrible, but he'll like it just like he likes cheeseburgers. Sorry everyone! (DN)

Floyd Gottfredson
I'm way behind on these by now (too many reprints), but Gottfredson's Mickey Mouse comics are as reliably, wholesomely entertaining as midcentury serial adventure gets. Those looking to keep their Twin Peaks fix going might like this one, as apparently it mainly involves Mickey against an evil doppelganger, "alienating his friends and committing crimes in Mickey's name." Maybe Lynch's childhood inspiration? [$35, TH]

Yuichi Yokoyama

What does one say about Yokoyama? The last time I saw him was July of 2011. We had an amazing dinner together. He did the ordering. I love that guy. This is his new book, all about, you guessed it, a group of humanoids wandering in an icy place. He's the best. (DN)

Juann Cabal, Will Conrad, Gabriel Guzman, Derlis Santacruz

This exists and is sold in stores to adults who frequent comic stores. There was a first volume successful enough that they published another. Harmless pastime or sign of generational passivity and decadence? [$15, TH]

15 Responses to This Week’s Comics (9/6/17)

  1. Is it okay if I post a job opening listing for this position?

  2. Sammy says:

    Welcome home, dan.

  3. Dan Nadel says:

    It’s just a temporary cottage.

  4. I would volunteer to fill the position of writing about interesting comics coming out every week, but as a relatively smaller blogger the idea of trying to fill Joe’s knowledgeable shoes is terrifying. It would be like going from the best lover you ever had to…I guess me? Whatever the case, in either scenario everyone’s embarrassed afterwards and I wouldn’t be able to find my pants.

  5. Geoff conkers says:

    What about da horrible design of Iceland???? Very ugly production of beautiful work. Seems like a hard ball to drop. Surely Designs self?? And yet… and yet…. somehow

  6. Conrad Groth says:

    Boo, these are the laziest reviews yet from TCJ. Sounds like you grabbed a stack of books, flipped through them for 5 minutes, and lazily typed whatever first came to mind. These are pathetic, typo-ridden ramblings.

    And did you even open the Grosz book? If you bother to read through it, it tells a pretty gripping story.

  7. Billy Foss says:


  8. Simon Hanselmann says:

    Are you attempting to take some heat off of RJ, Conrad?

  9. Cut Both Ways says:

    Golf clap for converting a “deep well of rage” into casually dismissive remarks like “But other people like this, I think?” and “This exists and is sold in stores to adults who frequent comic stores.”

    But other people like this feature, I think?

  10. Dan Nadel says:

    Conrad, I agree, definitely lazy, but they’re supposed to be just teeny little opinionated descriptions, not formal reviews. However, yes, I did read Grosz and honestly I really didn’t like it. I don’t like the aping of Grosz’s style — it serves no purpose other than to demonstrate how great Grosz really was in comparison. Fiske’s version has the stiff, inexpressive and mannered feel of 1990s illustration. And the structure of short gag-like strips basically turns Grosz into Clowes’ Wilson, which seems lazy and not very useful. I’m tired of the “artist as funny grump” genre. Basically, in structure and tone I felt like the book could have been about anyone, and in its particulars it does nothing to add to or expand our understanding of Grosz.

  11. RBronstein says:

    Uh oh. I smell a conspiracy…


  12. Briany Najar says:

    Drawing Grosz the way Grosz drew his targets is indeed offensive and tasteless.
    If that cover’s anything to go by, it’s also arrogant and over-reaching to a nigh-on psychotic degree.

  13. Conrad G says:

    Dan, I’m glad you added this follow up that really pinpoints your criticism of the book. I just didn’t get any sense from your brief review that you had actually looked at it. It seemed like you just hated it on principle. The combination of you giving Grosz short shrift and then essentially saying about Iceland, “I went to dinner with this guy; read his book!” annoyed me. But keep up the fire, Dan!

    And @RBronstein: You are fake news!

  14. Dan Nadel says:

    Bronstein, forget movies. You need to “come work” for TCJ full time to expose the truth.
    C. Groth: I guess my memory of my times with Yokoyama really doesn’t translate since I explained nothing. Fair enough! But man, that last dinner was truly amazing. It was like 175 degrees farenheit in Tokyo and the combination of heat delirium, Yokoyama’s perpetually Buster Keaton-esque expression, endless beer and the best sushi I’ve ever had has blotted out a decade of publishing the guy and left me with just the one sensory memory. But none of that is relevant to anyone but me. And maybe… no, just me. That is all.

  15. I read about 11 to 15 books a week and would be happy to write them up for TCJ if you guys need some more coverage. Let me know.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *