This Week in Comics This Week in Comics

THIS WEEK IN COMICS! (11/21/12 – The Flower of My Secret)

I think it's fair to state that the Brooklyn Comics and Graphics Festival doesn't have quite so tight an aesthetic on display as it did early on. This is natural - artists evolve, and so the participating exhibitors, many returning from prior years, have gone off in slightly different directions, evolving at their own pace.

Nonetheless, I had never expected to see something like that to the left at this year's festival - an 8" x 5 1/2" digest comic with a glossy painted cover, 100 pages for two dollars. John Porcellino was selling 'em via his Spit and a Half distribution service (Ctrl+F "Satya"), and he told me the artist, one Em Satya, was Cambodian. As I know absolutely nothing about the Cambodian comics scene, I was pleased to see that the publisher -- Phnom Penh's Our Books -- had included a generous six-page biography of the artist in the back of the book, complete with select (b&w) illustrations from his varied career in novel cover illustration, children's books, and comics.

Apparently, Flower of Battambang is his first book in the graphic novel format, though I'll confess I was a bit more taken by the disclosure that the story was influenced in parts by both Cambodian classical art and Indian cinema.

The art in Flower of Battambang, particularly its early pages, displays a pretty striking grasp of simple page design; I don't think there's a single page in the story with more than four panels on it, so an illustrative, almost poster-like aesthetic prevails. Per his bio, it took Satya over a decade and a half to finish the story; initially nobody was interested in publishing the work he'd completed, and then he suffered a stroke, and essentially taught himself to draw again in the process of completing the book. There is indeed a noticeable shift in drawing among different pages -- of course, I have no idea in which sequence the pages were completed -- where both the figure work dials back in detail to a more gestural feel, and, at other times, the pages become dominated by splash images bedecked with explanatory text, with characters showing a heavier shading attributed to the artist's latter-day interests.

As such, the book is both a story, and also a struggle, half-understood by the reader as the artist's mission to complete that long goal of making comics.

This is one of the 'heavier' pages, depicting hero Sotha's transformation into a popular music star; were this a proper Bollywood movie, we'd be hearing all of his chart-topping hits, but Satya maintains an illustrative distance, as if we're only receiving occasional scene transmissions from the movie in his head. As far as Bollywood goes -- I'm limiting this to Hindi-language cinema, both as an educated guess and because "Satya" is, coincidentally, a Hindi term meaning "Truth" -- this is a very mainline romance, with the hero and heroine standing as idealized avatars of virtue. I do not know how this scheme has been applied to Cambodian cultural mores, but know that Sotha is a gentle, humble soul who only wants to love Phalla, who is nonetheless shamed by her paramour's former association with a dangerous biker gang, and falls into the arms of a conniving rich boy who speaks indecently to women and deals drugs on the side. Sotha sings, then, to remind his love of his enduring affections, even in the face of the sort of flighty, spunky Supporting Girl character I always, personally, tend to think is a better match for these guys, though their outspokenness can never quite compare to the demure glow of the down-home good girl heroine.

Everything turns out okay in the end, though mystery remains as to the state of international comics. The more I think I learn, the more there is to know. I presume you can try and hit up John P. for a little dose of your own, if you're so inclined.


PLEASE NOTE: What follows is not a series of capsule reviews but an annotated selection of items listed by Diamond Comic Distributors for release to comic book retailers in North America on the particular Wednesday, or, in the event of a holiday or occurrence necessitating the close of UPS in a manner that would impact deliveries, Thursday, identified in the column title above. Not every listed item will necessarily arrive at every comic book retailer, in that some items may be delayed and ordered quantities will vary. I have in all likelihood not read any of the comics listed below, in that they are not yet released as of the writing of this column, nor will I necessarily read or purchase every item identified; THIS WEEK IN COMICS! reflects only what I find to be potentially interesting.



The Library of American Comics Essentials Vol. 1: Baron Bean: The 328-page start of a new line of classic newspaper strip hardcovers, and what better artist to start with than George Herriman? Much of his non-Krazy Kat output remains somewhat obscure, though publisher IDW has vowed to collect the entirety of this 1916-19 replacement daily strip for The Dingbat Family (aka: the feature from which Krazy Kat spun off), an ex-nobleman/active bum scenario redolent (so I'm told) of Herriman's affection for wildly popular Chaplin movie comedies of the day. The reason it's gonna take several volumes is because IDW is putting it out one strip per page in 4.25" x 11" landscape format. Note that the Baron Bean installments of this series will not arrive sequentially - vol. 2 is already reserved for 1933 installments of Cliff Sterrett's Polly and Her Pals, while vol. 3 will concern a 1928-29 storyline from Sidney Smith's The Gumps; $19.99.

Thermae Romae Vol. 1: Certainly the big manga debut of the week, this is Yen Press' 368-page(!) oversized(!!) hardcover edition of one of those runaway hits on a topic that just piques the interest: baths. Specifically, Japanese public baths, as seen through the eyes of an ancient Roman architect shuttling back and forth through time for a bit of cultural cross-pollination. Created by Mari Yamazaki, the seinen series remains ongoing today, having recently released its fifth collected volume -- the Yen editions look to be compiling two Japanese books in each -- and seen itself adapted into a feature film that apparently grossed nearly $75 million in Japanese theaters. BATHS. Production info; $34.99.



Digestate: Mmmm, comics about baths and food. This is my kind of week. A Kickstarter campaign ran late last spring to fund this 250+ page collection of b&w comics related to eating and the many issues related thereto, and it's got a very interesting lineup; I don't recall Adam Hines of Duncan the Wonder Dog appearing in anything else since that big book dropped. Other contributors include Renée French, Noah Van Sciver, Alex Robinson, Jeffrey Brown, Brian Ralph, James Kochalka, Kieth Knight, Sam Henderson, Danny Hellman, Kevin Cannon, John Kerschbaum, K. Thor Jensen, Darryl Ayo Brathwaite, L. Nichols, Box Brown and others. The editor is J.T. Yost, of Birdcage Bottom Books; $19.95.

Tune Vol. 1: Vanishing Point: Your YA-ish choice for the week, a First Second collection of a webcomic by Derek Kirk Kim & Les McClaine, a sci-fi comedy about an underemployed young fellow trapped in an alien zoo; $16.99.

Edgar Allan Poe's The Conqueror Worm: You heard it here first, True Believer, and now the time has come to plunk down your sweet dollars for 32 pages of creepy comics adapted, drawn and colored by Richard Corben, as informed by the poem of the title. Note that Corben also has a shorter Poe adaptation (Shadow) in Dark Horse Presents #18 this week. Preview; $3.50.

Marked Man: Also hailing from Dark Horse Presents is this 72-page Howard Chaykin serial, bucking the trend of collecting that anthology's goods into comic book form by appearing as a 6 5/8" x 10 3/16" hardcover. A vain, aging career criminal is snapped into attentiveness by uncaring brutality of a connected political family - it's the kind of harsh-yet-easygoing genre scenario you tend to see a little more of in foreign comics traditions, though Chaykin's one of the few writer/artists serving 'em up at a regular clip in North America. Samples; $14.99.

Saturn Apartments Vol. 6 (of 7): Getting back to manga, Viz demonstrates some measure of dedication to its own seinen offerings, despite contractions in the market (one presumes) putting 'em mostly on the slow boat - don't expect the seventh and final installment until May 2013. I do like Hisae Iwaoka's art a good deal, so you know I'd flip through this. Other Viz offerings include: vol. 7 (of 11) for Mohiro Kitoh's raw nerve kids 'n giant robots opus Bokurano: Ours; vol. 13 (of 14, probably; maybe - I guess?) for Yoshiyuki Sadamoto's take on '90s raw nerve kids 'n giant robots urtext Neon Genesis Evangelion; and vol. 11 (of who knows) for Takehiko Inoue's ongoing wheelchair basketball series Real. Many choices; $12.99 (each, save for Eva, which is $9.99).

The Grand Duke: Random French stuff from Archaia #1 - a 144-page hardcover translation of a 2008-10 series by aviation art specialist Romain Hugault and longtime BD scriptwriter Yannick "Yann" le Pennetier. It's a love story between German and Russian pilots - I recall a Garth Ennis Battlefields storyline with Dynamite also dealing with the female Soviet "Night Witches" of the time. Preview; $24.95.

Last Days of an Immortal: Random French stuff from Archaia #2 - I also recall Boom! putting out a comic titled 7 Psychopaths a while back (no relation to the Martin McDonagh film). It was written by Fabien Vehlmann, currently the writer of perennial BD youth franchise Spirou et Fantasio. This is a more adult-oriented Vehlmann script, a 152-page album from 2010 with art by Gwen de Bonneval. An investigator with the "philosophical police" seeks to resolve an inter-species war by journeying to the heart of their centuries-old animosity. Preview; $24.95.

Nexus Omnibus Vol. 1: Man, did you know those fifty dollar Nexus hardcovers from Dark Horse are up to vol. 12? They're getting pretty close to compiling the entirety of Mike Baron's & Steve Rude's signature superhero/sci-fi series - one of the beloved indie genre comics from the '80s and beyond. That's good news for shy kids and bargain hunters, 'cause now the publisher is into the re-packaging phase, with the first two hardcovers stuffed into this one low(er)-cost softcover volume, 416 pages to kick off a whole line; $24.99.

Judge Dredd #1: Being the debut of the second attempt to turn the Hon. Joseph Dredd into a North American comic book mainstay, following a 1994-96 attempt by DC... around the last time a movie came and went, in fact. Some really decent talent involved with that old series; Andy Helfer, he of that terrific '87-'89 run on The Shadow, with Michael Avon Oeming and J.H. Williams III as succeeding primary artists. Still, everyone was either a bit green or off-balance - it's not well-remembered for a reason. Here's hoping writer Duane Swierczynski and artist Nelson Daniel have a better time of it, tracking events from the character's early career with IDW. They'll be aided by Paul Gulacy-drawn back-up, and some essay content by Douglas Wolk. Preview; $3.99.

The Batman/Judge Dredd Collection: Granted, there were other Dredd appearances in North American comics, most of which are compiled into this 304-page hardcover devoted to (title notwithstanding) all of the Law's self-contained crossovers with Batman and Lobo, characters often written by 2000 AD veteran Alan Grant, who scripts the various comics here in collaboration with Dredd co-creator John Wagner. Art by Simon Bisley, Glenn Fabry, Cam Kennedy, Val Semeiks and others; $29.99.

The Art of Todd McFarlane: The Devil's in the Details: Finally, we see a 400-page, Image-published hardcover showcase for the Spawn creator, notable for the fact that I can't recall seeing any art books for this like-it-or-not-generation-definer before, and I suspect the production will be pretty nice; $64.99.


CONFLICT OF INTEREST RESERVOIR: I do believe Castle Waiting Vol. II #18 wraps up the current storyline for Linda Medley's long-running fantasy comic, and with it my knowledge of the present state of the series; $3.95.


15 Responses to THIS WEEK IN COMICS! (11/21/12 – The Flower of My Secret)

  1. Jeppe says:

    I am very excited about that Thermae Romae volume. The film looks fairly promising as well – Hideki Takeuchi is certainly a competent director, who has plenty of experience adapting seinen manga for the screen (although most of the work I’m familiar with has been in the form of TV shows).

  2. Martin Wisse says:

    Third attempt for Judge Dredd, surly, after the “original” Quality Comics reprints in the eighties?

  3. Joe McCulloch says:

    Oh, I’m only counting original stuff aimed at NA readers… UK-derived reprints are another (longer) matter…

  4. mateor says:

    What does Doug Wolk know about Judge Dredd?

    Probably just Sly Stallone fanfic.

  5. Joe McCulloch says:

    No Mateor, that’s my contribution to Judge Dredd: Legends of the Law Part 2: Form and Void, which I intend to Kickstart on my own behalf through a variety of shell corporations and assumed names. Splundig vur thrigg!

  6. mateor says:


    I got five on it.

  7. Jim Sheridan says:

    I sure do hope Dark Horse continues with the Nexus reprints!! From what I have seen on Steve Rude’s facebook page, he does not really know what Dark Horse plans to do next. However, it has been very enjoyable to read those stories again.

  8. Joe McCulloch says:

    Having now read the comic, I can definitely say it’s a good deal of fun, if very rigidly formulaic – by the end of the book (which is to say, the end of the Japanese vol. 2) you do sort of get the impression that Yamazaki might be getting a little tired of having this guy ‘accidentally’ travel through time every single chapter to learn some exciting fact about Japanese bathing habits and verily apply said knowledge to solve some problem back in Rome… and always with plenty of clenched-fist affirmations of the excellence of Japanese culture!

    That said, part of the fun, I admit, is seeing how the artist’s very well-researched visions of Roman culture, politics and militarism *always* somehow relate back to bathing — that greatest of human endeavors — despite an actual plot gradually bubbling up over time; there’s a terrifically cheesy cliffhanger that closes out the book, like something out of a Dan Brown novel, but a lot more charming coming from a semi-educational comic about baths.

    Really nice production on the book, btw… I enjoyed Yamazaki’s little essays after every chapter, which primarily serves to explain the historical basis behind all the crap her lead character ‘learns’ from Japan, although I was pretty amused by how varied a life Yamazaki seems to have led. A lot of mangaka don’t seem to think about anything other than comics, going off their back-of-book notes, but this particular author seems more prone to exploring Turkey or serving interpreter for an Italian orchestra… maybe a side-effect of not getting into comics professionally until you’re almost 30? She also shouts out Yoshiharu Tsuge and Suehiro Maruo…!

  9. mateor says:

    This write up here makes me want to pick up the book in a way that the preview never could. At this poiny, you could tell me there was a Japanese comic (or food product) consisting of just about anything and I would believe you.

  10. Tony says:

    There is a very rigidly formulaic manga out there? Stop the presses!

  11. Kim Thompson says:

    Interesting list, although of course it suffers from the TCJ Top 100 problem of lumping together 50-year syndicated comics runs, single graphic novels, and single albums within a series. The “essentials” (as opposed to “best” or “greatest”) also suggests a tilt toward groundbreaking or historically significant books as opposed to actual best: I don’t think anyone would list LAPINOT ET LES CAROTTES DE PATAGONIE as Lewis’s best book, for instance. (It might not make the Best Top 100 Lewis Trondheim books!) Ditto ADIEU BRINDAVOINE for Tardi.

    Note that the book LA VOITURE IMMERGEE is our MURDER BY HIGH TIDE.

  12. Jeppe says:

    Thanks for adding this write up, Joe!
    Between references to Suehiro Maruo and examinations of the link between Roman militarism and bathing, there is no way I can avoid picking up this book.

  13. Pingback: Happy Holidays from Our Books | Our Books

  14. Pingback: Our Books Cambodia – Happy Holidays from Our Books

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *