Today's news
(Potpourri) Another day, another collection of news and links. Here we go:
- Diamond has released its pamphlet and book top-100 lists for 2003, which is available at Newsarama. How you interpret the lists depends upon your tastes, of course. If you're a superhero fan, you can scroll lazily down the column and see your favorite titles. If you're not, the lists can seem depressing and mildly depressing, respectively; the comics-pamphlets list is a dizzying study in monomania, while there are a few intriguing breaks in genre among the book collections. The most promising entry is 30 Days of Night, a straightforward horror novel, which clocks in at #4 on the booklist; indeed, non-superhero titles dot the top 100 graphic novels in such a way as to make one wonder if the potential might just exist for genre diversity in books even if comics pamphlets themselves are basically a lost cause. As Matt Brady notes in his commentary, Tokyopop actually managed to place five books on the list. Still, it's the topmost list on the page, the publisher rankings, which tell the real story: between them, Marvel, DC and Image earn 70.37% of the dollars generated by initial sales through Diamond to the direct market. The next three publishers on the list -- Dark Horse, CrossGen and Dreamwave -- account for 11.26%, leaving everyone else fighting it out for the crumbs.
By contrast, check out the fourth item (currently) on French-language comics news-site BD Paradisio's news page, which offers a breakdown of 2003 comics sales in France. Glénat, the top-producing publisher in the Fifth Republic, is responsible for just 8.11% of the material released last year; you have to scroll down to the twentieth largest comics publisher to hit a market share of under 1%, compared to the tenth publisher among Diamond's clientele. Oh, there's a diverse array of American comics publishers, make no mistake, but with so much real estate claimed by the top three superhero publishers, they're forced to seek their fortunes elsewhere if they ever wish to grow as companies. Given all of this, the "mildly depressing" news to be found in the Diamond graphic-novel list is actually something of a step up. (That last link courtesy of Fumetti.org's Gianfranco Goria.)
- For a snapshot of entirely different comics scene, take a look at Anime On DVD's recap of the past year in manga. (Link via Shawn Fumo.)
- Rich Johnston looks at Marvel and DC's new conservatism (top item) and CrossGen's allegedly increasing mendacity in attempting to cajol art out of creators without paying them (middle of page).
- Mark Evanier notes that cartoonist Dave Cockrum is slowly recovering, and has been taken off the respirator that was helping him breathe during a serious battle with pneumonia.
- How popular a webcomic is Penny Arcade? Put it this way: the folks at Comixpedia suspect that a link from the webcomic to a review of same on their site was responsible for overwhelming it, forcing an unexpected upgrade to a new server. As Penny Arcade co-creator Tycho currently notes on his homepage, "I don't know how to feel about the position we occupy in the context of Webcomics, I honestly try not to think about it. The one thing I do know, we could kill another webcomic creator in cold blood and get away with it."
- Egon points out that the Charles M. Schulz Museum is collecting the artist's pre-Peanuts comics work, including the early panel Li'l Folks, into a new archival volume, entitled Charles M. Schulz: Li'l Beginnings. The book is set to debut February 21st, and will be available both at the museum and its online store.
- Jesse Sunenblick details the difficulties faced by editorial cartoonists and illustrators for The Columbia Journalism Review.
- The Denver Post's Kyle MacMillan examines today's comics industry, and includes a few figures to put the competing markets of the 21st century in perspective. (Link via ArtsJournal.)
- Silver Bullet Comics' Tim O'Shea interviews Jennifer Daydreamer, whose second comic book for Top Shelf is set to be released soon.
- Also at Silver Bullet Comics: Darren Schroeder speaks with U.K self-publishing comics writer Sean Michael Wilson, who collaborated with Argentinean artist Jorge Heufemann on the forthcoming book Angel of the Woods.
- Writing for his weblog, Canadian op-ed pundit Colby Cosh (temporary link) takes an admiring look at Chester Brown's presentation of history in Louis Riel.
- In his column for Broken Frontier (also a temporary link), Graeme McMillan wonders if DC Comics' new "Focus" line isn't just Marvel's New Universe dressed up in different clothes -- actual clothes, mind you, not brightly-colored underwear -- then guesses from the size of the lettering that the line is destined for manga-volume format.
- Sean Collins highlights the lack of standards among the comics press by comparing how several recent interview fiascos would look if committed by the national news media.
- Four Color Hell's Todd Murray looks at that magical space where retailer-turned-columnist Brian Hibbs and cartoonist-turned-goofball John Byrne meet. I think there's an important distinction being missed here, actually: Hibbs is offering advice to retailers, whereas Byrne is chiding readers for what is largely a reader-driven phenomenon in the first place. In other words, Hibbs is merely telling his fellow professionals to exercise caution, while Byrne is telling the customer to order for his benefit, not their own.
- Mike Sterling offers "the comic book retailer's bill of rights."
- Eddie Mitchell finds himself torn between supporting his local comics retailer and supporting his local, graphic-novel minded, independent bookseller.
- For those of you looking for manga recommendations, Pam Korda's doing a yeoman's job of it right now. Click here and here for examples.
- Steven Berg explains in exact detail why Bill Jemas' never-used proposal for a Thor miniseries is so brain-bustingly stupid.
Finally, if someone could please explain to me just what the hell David Fiore is talking about, I'd be much obliged. Specifically:
"What we really need is for Grant Morrison to return to his Animal Man form (possibly with some help from Roy Thomas on letters pages/historiography and Stan Lee on bulletins... I know, I know -- this is starting to sound like the Public Enemy line-up: who gets to be media assassin?) The genre's greatest strength is its capacity to embed the 'Uncanny' (through recurrence) in a skewed 'continuity' that collapses an entire human life span into a zone of prime awareness... (we get to deal loss and memory -- unobscured by the tired narratives of aging and 'progressing toward wisdom' -- on a scale that no finite medium can approach) Every new monthly issue has the potential to add to the greatness of a series, and there's no reason ever to stop the cycle (because it never really gets started) -- it's a serial 'jam session'!"
Huh? How exactly does this statement describe superhero comics, but not, say, television series like Doctor Who or Northern Exposure, or Godzilla movies, or V.C. Andrews novels, or... you could go all day throwing examples out there. How is the ability to tell an endless series of stories limited by a group of restrictive tropes that can be maintained by an endless string of faceless hacks a "greatest strength" unique -- or even best performed -- by superhero comics? This sounds like pseudo-intellectual nonsense used to gussy up after-the-fact justifications of personal taste to me. Am I missing something here?
(A side note: game designer Bruce Baugh offers some advice to David Fiore: get used to change.)
Posted @ 4:40 AM by Dirk Deppey | permalink
Monday, January 19th, 2004
Today's news
(Potpourri) Due to a variety of projects, I'm going to be pressed for time for the next few weeks, so apologies in advance for the coming lack of essays and extended commentary. To the other half of my reading audience: you're welcome. Here's the round-up of last weekend's news and links:
- In Algeria, editorial cartoonist Ali Dilem of the French-language newspaper Liberté was summoned by the police for questioning Saturday, along with Mohamed Benchicou, the executive editor for independent Algerian newspaper Le Matin, over cartoons and/or articles critical of that nation's president, Abdelaziz Bouteflika. The two men were released after questioning, according to an Associated Press report posted to CNN's website. As noted here previously, this is by no means the first time Dilem has found himself facing down government intimidation; back in May of last year Dilem was given a suspended six-month sentence and a fine of 20,000 dinars (just under $300) for "attacks on the army involving abuse, insult or defamation," which is to say criticising the Algerian army's commanders in print, under a law so widely believed to have been passed specifically to muzzle him that it's commonly referred to as "the Dilem amendment." The intimidation has continued ever since.
- Yesterday's episode of Johnny Hart's strip B.C. (not archived on the site as of this writing) was pulled from a number of newspapers yesterday, including The Washington Post and The Dallas Morning News. At issue is the punchline of the strip's aeronautical joke: "Two Wongs don't make a Wright." The Morning News' Mike Peters explains why his paper pulled the strip.
- The Young Adult Library Services Association has announced its 2004 list of best books for young adults. Among the 84 selected titles are four graphic novels: Craig Thompson's Blankets, Jason Little's Shutterbug Follies, Jeff Parker's The Interman and Marjane Satrapi's Persepolis. Comics also featured in several related lists released at the same time by the organization. Among their "quick picks for reluctant young adult readers" are Simpsons Comics Madness, Brian Michael Bendis et. al.'s Ultimate Spider-Man Vol. 2, Ron Marz et. al.'s The Path: Crisis of Faith, two books from the Bill Willingham'written series Fables, as well as the aforementioned Shutterbug Follies. Finally, the group announced several themed lists of "popular paperbacks", and comics fared well in the "If It Weren’t For Them: Heroes" category, with showings by Brian Michael Bendis and Mark Bagley's Ultimate Spider-Man: Double Trouble, Jules Feiffer's The Great Comic Book Heroes, Mike Kunkel's Herobear and the Kid: The Inheritance, Mark Millar and Brian Hitch's The Ultimates: Super-Human, James Robinson and Tony Harris' Starman: Sins of the Father and Stan Sakai's Usagi Yojimbo: Duel at Kitanoji. (First link via Newsarama.)
- Digital-rights management watchdog site DRM Watch presents its round-up of 2003. E-publishing is mentioned only briefly -- there were simply too many setbacks for such content-protection schemes in other media last year which needed reporting -- but the report does note that "The e-book market suffered from flat overall growth, but Adobe began to emerge as the prevailing platform in that niche, with MobiPocket appearing poised for momentum in the coming year as more reading-friendly mobile devices appear." Oddly, no mention was made of the Japanese initiative we've been tracking for over a year now. (Link via Slashdot.)
- Newsarama's Matt Brady offers his analysis for Direct Market sales through Diamond Distributors in December.
- Aardwolf Publishing is in the process of assembling a benefit book, The Uncanny Dave Cockrum Tribute, to help raise money for the ailing illustrator. Check it out.
- Kyle Buchanan chats with minicomics wunderkind Souther Salazar for Ostrich Ink. (Link via Rick Bradford.)
- Ninth Art's Alex Dueben interviews Kurt Wolfgang, creator of Where Hats Go and editor of the minicomix anthology Lo-Jinx.
- Writing for Oregon's Portland Tribune, Michaela Bancud profiles cartoonist Arnold Pander about his latest project: black velvet paintings.
- A recent online chat at The Washington Post (registration required) featured Denis Lebrun, the artist currently drawing the legacy comic strip Blondie.
- Lorrie Cohen of Arizona newspaper The Tucson Citizen sits down for a chat with Sandra Bell-Lundy, the creator of the daily comic strip Between Friends.
- Staying with my home state for a moment: The Arizona Republic's Michael Senft pays a visit to Phoenix shop Samurai Comics, where manga and anime has become big business for store-owners Mike and Moryha Banks.
- The Honolulu Star Bulletin's Burl Burlingame reviews Jack Jackson's graphic novel, Commanche Moon.
- Retailer Brian Hibbs is writing his "Tilting at Windmills" column again, this time for Newsarama. If you have an interest in following the Direct Market as a business, this is the best news you've heard in the last six months. It's already spawning commentary -- here's Jim Henley's take on the new column.
- Heading back to Ninth Art for a moment: Paul O'Brien takes a look at the last Tuesday's conviction of Japanese publisher Motonori Kishi on obscenity charges.
- Comic Book Resources' James Sime offers independent publishers advice on sending mailers and freebies to Direct Market retailers, and why they should consider doing so. Added bonus: a 75% reduction in those godawful "pimp" metaphors!
- Modern Tales (temporary link) impressario Joey Manley compares videogame culture of the past to webcomics culture of the present day, and states his belief that online cartoons have a similar upward arc ahead of them.
- You know, if you ignore the self-aggrandizing bullshit, Beau Smith's latest column for Silver Bullet Comics, which argues for greater diversity in the marketplace, makes some pretty good points.
- Last Friday I was so taken with weblogger John Jakala's take on Shonen Jump circulation figures that I completely forgot to also link to this piece, which compares the differing definitions of "genre diversity" at Marvel and DC.
- Allen Berrebbi speculates upon what Diamond Distributors could be doing to further the reach and selling power of the Direct Market. (Note: it's a new Blogspot site, so the permalinks don't work; look for the top entry under "Saturday, January 17.")
- Monitor Duty's Michael Hutchison offers the "They Read Comics" promo ad that Rich Johnston forgot to write.
- Four Color Hell's Michele Catalano imagines Popeye's life at 75 years of age. Ah Guh Guh Guh!
- Scaryduck reminisces about the first issue of British comics institution 2000 AD. (Link via Darren Shrubsole.)
- Jason Marcy wonders why comics webloggers haven't been updating their sites lately. I've been wondering about Alan David Doane (who just updated after almost a week's absence) and Sean Collins myself, and Matt Fraction's blog has been removed altogether. On the other hand, Marcy also mentions this weblog, which maintained its regular schedule all last week. This leads me to believe that Mr. Marcy might need to clear his browser cache.
- Writing for Continuity Pages, Bryan Miller reviews superhero comics that range from very bad to merely treading water, and in quite entertaining fashion -- the reviews, that is, not the comics.
- I've seen this before, but never reproduced publicly: an unnamed member of The Comics Waiting Room has posted Bill Jemas' proposal for a never-published miniseries, The People's Thor. Gosh, that Jemas sure was a wellspring of creativity, wasn't he? (Note: Blogspot, permalinks -- you know the drill. It's the top entry under "Friday, January 16.")
- From March 1942 in all its cheesy glory, here's Planet Comics #17. (Link via Boing Boing's Mark Frauenfelder.)
Finally, remember last Friday, when Brian Hibbs wrote:
""According to the 12/21 Bookscan #s (The market penetration of which can certainly be argued, but it is the only data point we have) the ACTUAL SALES of the newly manga-formatted Elfquest: Wolfrider V.1 into 'real' bookstores was 846 copies. [...]"
-- and my response:
"Let's begin with a question. My understanding is that DC Comics is re-releasing the Elfquest saga in at least two seperate formats: a regular trade-paperback series targetted to the Direct Market, and a line of smaller, manga-sized volumes for the bookstores. Which variety is this? [...]"
Remember that? Man, I kill me. Writing a weblog half-awake at 3 AM, I frequently pull little goof-ups like this. Don't get me wrong, I like writing this thing, but I often find myself hating having written it...
Posted @ 3:15 AM by Dirk Deppey | permalink